Luminous Landscape Forum
The Art of Photography => User Critiques => Topic started by: Slobodan Blagojevic on October 29, 2010, 10:25:51 pm
-
Given that I recently offered some harsh critique of images posted in this forum, I thought it is only fair to open myself for the same :)
(Click on the image to see it larger)
-
Given that I recently offered some harsh critique of images posted in this forum, I thought it is only fair to open myself for the same :)
(Click on the image to see it larger)
Two options:
United Colours (Underpants) of Benetton;
The Flying Burrito Brothers play Bel Air.
Nice tight formation, whoever you shot!
Rob C
-
Red, white & black! Nazi kites! Oops, Godwin's Law
-
Slobodan, as you're far from being a beginner and that I know what kind of good images you are able to produce,
this image is indeed an open door from criticsm bombing ;D,
Keeping in mind that we are not talking about a beginner but an honorable veteran, right?
- There is no movement captured in the paralell curves wich makes the image too static
- The tint of the blue sky is boring and clouds have a dominance that doesn't help
- Saturation of the sky could be less to not compete with the colors of the subject
- the composition tells nothing, it's messy, too far and would deserve a good cropping and putting the axix to the bottom paralell for example
in fact, a banal and boring image in the very long list of aerial shows snapshots.
Have I been harsh enough? Or you want more...
-
Slobodan, as you're far from being a beginner and that I know what kind of good images you are able to produce,
this image is indeed an open door from criticsm bombing ;D,
Keeping in mind that we are not talking about a beginner but an honorable veteran, right?
- There is no movement captured in the paralell curves wich makes the image too static
- The tint of the blue sky is boring and clouds have a dominance that doesn't help
- Saturation of the sky could be less to not compete with the colors of the subject
- the composition tells nothing, it's messy, too far and would deserve a good cropping and putting the axix to the bottom paralell for example
in fact, a banal and boring image in the very long list of aerial shows snapshots.
Have I been harsh enough? Or you want more...
You should try criticizing it instead of praising it? :)
-
It was a joke Stamper, I was teasing Slobodan.
-
It was a joke Stamper, I was teasing Slobodan.
Fred, for 50€/day (each!), can I have those two girls added to the package for France too?
Rob C
-
Slobodan is feeding us red (and black and white) herrings ....
-
Rob :o, are you revealing your hidden nature?
What, do you think I'm a spendthrift?
;-)
Rob
-
I don't think it's quite awful enough. Don't you have anything that's more awful?
-
… Have I been harsh enough? Or you want more...
Fred, this isn't funny… there have been several suicides in the States recently, from kids to teenagers, as a result of cyber-bullying (i.e., harsh online criticism, threats and insults).
Is that what you are doing to me here, Fred? ???
… Is it, Fred? :( :(
… Is it!? :'( :'( :'(
-
Yes!! ;D ;D
But we have a french say that goes like this: "qui aime bien châtie bien"
wich means: "the one who loves well punishes well" ;)
-
Seems like everything is heading in the general direction of down...
-
Seems like everything is heading in the general direction of down...
No, Chris, my image was NOT meant as a comment on the general direction LuLa is heading :D
-
No, Chris, my image was NOT meant as a comment on the general direction LuLa is heading :D
Now, now, Slobodan; most of us had forgotten about the clunky new mechanics; thought it had always required using Word in order to write more than a couple of lines...
;-)
Rob C
-
It was a joke Stamper, I was teasing Slobodan.
And so was my reply! ::)